Reception highlights CityU School of Law competition success

Twenty-one Juris Doctor (JD) and Bachelor of Laws with Honours (LLB) students led by the School of Law (SLW) of City University of Hong Kong (CityU) participated in six international / regional mooting competitions during the 2008-09 academic year. To recognise the academic advancement and self-development of these students, SLW held a reception on 28 April.

In six mooting competitions, the SLW teams earned eight honours in four, including the Frankfurt Investment Arbitration Moot, Manfred Lachs Space Law Moot Court Competition, Foreign Direct Investment International Moot Competition and the Sixth Annual Willem C. Vis (East) International Commercial Arbitration Moot. (For award details, please refer to the Appendix).

“The members of the University community who won at international competitions demonstrate the success of the University in nurturing and developing the internationally recognised talent of students. Participation in the mooting competition fosters cross-cultural exchange of ideas and cements relationships throughout the worldwide university community,” said Mr Leung Chun-ying, Council Chairman of CityU.

“I hope these students will help train their fellow students, so the whole school will benefit,” said Professor Richard Ho Yan-ki, Provost of CityU.

Professor Wang Guiguo, Dean of SLW, said, “Since the academic year 2008-09, the School has placed more emphasis on mooting, as it is an essential skill for the students to master. We believe this enhances students’ research capabilities and advocacy and critical thinking skills. Our students’ success demonstrates that CityU Law School has attained the international benchmark of world-class law schools and that our students are able to compete globally.”

This month, three law students, including JD student Fiona Chan Ngok-man, and LLB students Fiona Leung Nga-woon and Ryan Law Tak-him, defeated 22 teams from international universities and were named runner-up in the Asia Pacific regional round of the Manfred Lachs Space Law Moot Court Competition. It was the second time SLW became the sole Chinese team to earn honours in such a prestigious international mooting competition, following success in the Frankfurt Investment Arbitration Moot. Fiona Chan won Best Oralist in the Asia Pacific regional round. The winning team was coached by Dr Vernon Nase, Visiting Fellow of SLW.

“Where Australian students have approximately three months of free time over their summer break, Hong Kong students have only a couple of weeks of spare research time around Christmas,” said Dr Nase, who has extensive moot training experience at foreign universities. “Our three students were dedicated, hard-working and extremely professional in their preparation for the moot. It has been a great privilege to work with them and to know that they achieved international excellence.”

Fiona Chan’s Best Oralist title came in her first mooting competition. She said she refined the art of advocacy during the competition. Her teammate Ryan Law was also participating in his first competition. “Our team did not have any case references or experience in the use of anti-satellite and integrated space based defence systems in Hong Kong. We needed to put in extra time and effort over a fortnight to study international law and current affairs regarding the national defence in foreign countries.”

In moot court competitions, students are required to research a complex hypothetical scenario, prepare written papers and participate in courtroom hearings. Moot competition is an effective means to prepare for legal practice and hone advocacy skills.

Edward Tang Ho-ming, winner of an Honourable Mention for Best Oral Advocate in the Sixth Annual Willem C. Vis (East) International Commercial Arbitration Moot 2009, said, “I am more confident about expressing myself and better prepared to be a barrister after taking the moot training. I also polished the skill of team building.”

At the celebration reception, SLW presented certificates to Mr Romesh Weeramantry, Assistant Professor of SLW and coach of the Frankfurt Investment Arbitration Moot Court Competition, and Mr Rajesh Sharma, Visiting Assistant Professor, to recognise the efforts of the moot coaching team.

Appendix: The list of international mooting competitions and honours of SLW

1.         Frankfurt Investment Arbitration Moot Court Competition (April 2009)

l   Runner-up

l   Winner of the Oxford University Press Award for the Best Team from a Non-OECD Country

2.         Manfred Lachs Space Law Moot Court Competition, Asia Pacific Regional Rounds (March 2009)

l   Regional Runners-Up 2009

l   Best Oralist in the Final Rounds: Fiona Chan Ngok-man,

3.         Foreign Direct Investment International Moot Competition (March 2009)

l   Ranked 6th out of 20 teams.

l   Honorable Mention Oralist: Candy Tang So-man

4.         Sixth Annual Willem C. Vis (East) International Commercial Arbitration Moot (October and November, 2008)

l   Honorable Mention For Best Memorandum on Behalf of Claimant

l   Honorable Mention For Best Oral Advocate: Edward Tang Ho-ming

For further media enquiries, please contact: